Plutonism?
Have you ever heard of Plutonism and Neptunism?
People used to argue about them!
Here is an excerpt from Wikipedia:Plutonism is the geologic theory that the igneous rocks forming the Earth originated from intrusive magmatic activity, with a continuing gradual process of weathering and erosion wearing away rocks, which were then deposited on the sea bed, re-formed into layers of sedimentary rock by heat and pressure, and raised again. It proposes that basalt is solidified molten magma. The theory lead to plutonic (intrinsic) rock classification, which includes intrinsic igneous rocks such as gabbro, diorite, granite and pegmatite. The name plutonism references Pluto, the classical ruler of the underworld and the Roman god of wealth. A main reason Pluto was incorporated into the classification was due to the plutonic rocks commonly being present in gold and silver ore deposits (veins).<sup class="reference">[1]</sup>
The Oxford English Dictionary traces use of the word "plutonists" to 1799,<sup class="reference">[2]</sup> and the appearance of the word plutonism to 1842.<sup class="reference">[3]</sup>
Abbé Anton Moro, who had studied volcanic islands, first proposed the theory before 1750, and James Hutton subsequently developed it as part of his Theory of the Earth,<sup class="reference">[4]</sup> published in 1788, which used rock formations at Glen Tilt in Perthshire as the prime example supporting his theory; an example used by Neptunism to prove their theory as well.<sup class="reference">[5]</sup> The idea contested Abraham Werner's neptunist theory which proposed that the Earth had formed from a mass of water and suspended material which had formed rocks as layers of deposited sediment which became the continents when the water retreated, further layers being deposited by floods and some volcanic activity.<sup class="reference">[5]</sup>
Plutonists strongly disputed the neptunist view that rocks had formed by processes that no longer operated, instead supporting Hutton's theory. A key issue of the debate revolved around the neptunist belief that basalt was sedimentary, and some fossils had been found in it. Against this, Hutton's supporter John Playfair (1748–1819) argued that this rock contained no fossils as it had formed from molten magma, and it had been found cutting through other rocks in volcanic dykes. The arguments continued into the early 19th century, and eventually the plutonist views on the origin of rocks prevailed in the wake of the work of Charles Lyell in the 1830s, who incorporated this theory into uniformitarianism.<sup class="reference">[5]</sup> However, geologists regard sedimentary rocks such as limestone as having resulted from processes like those described by the neptunists.<sup class="reference">[6]</sup><sup class="reference">[7]</sup>
Comparatively, plutonism within uniformitarianism is equivalent to neptunism within catastrophism, as both are used as core concepts within their respective theories, and hence similarly, neptunism opposes plutonism in the same way that catastrophism opposes uniformitarianism."
----------------------
An exponent of Neptunism was Werner. He expressed his ideas so:
Werner held that, generally speaking, nothing that we are able to observe of the accumulated layers within the earth's crust can be traced back to any kind of action by fire, but that everything we can learn from investigations points to the earth having in effect consolidated out of nothing but a watery element, out of a watery form of the planet, that even the oldest strata are alluvial deposits from water and that, consequently, granite too owes its origin not to the action of seething fire, but to watery deposits—and only in the course of time, through later occurrences, underwent changes which make its watery origin less apparent today.
Interesting right? but what do they mean?
So to summarize we have two theories about the original earth layers to be be derived from water (Neptunian) or fire (Plutonian).
Ancient men thought the earth originated from nature; and they conceived nature to have two creative sates; one being fire, and the other water, and that these were related to the titans Pluto and Neptune.
The adherents of the Neptunistic school saw the cause of all volcanic phenomena in processes which, through pressure from within, or through chemical conditions in the interior of the. Earth, made it possible for mighty catastrophes to take place in the interior and erupt outwards. At this juncture, events occurred which, in their upward trend, had the effect of pushing up mountain-massifs out of the interior of the earth.
0 comments